Why vote for Braun when he doesn’t deserve it?

Posted by Steve

Updated All-Star balloting was released today and Braun is up to fourth in the voting. Call me crazy, but my reaction to this was: Why?

Ryan Braun is tenth in OPS among National League outfielders with 175 ABs and a 34th in on-base percentage. He’s currently rocking a woeful .316 OBP.

People are pointing to his hit totals and home run totals, but that is already factored into OPS. Using home runs and OPS as two separate arguments for Braun making the team is like saying, “Brady Clark had 184 hits, AND 149 singles!”

Braun has been a player with incredible power and not much else. His slugging % is off the charts, but OBP is widely considered to be at least 1.8 times as important as slugging. He isn’t even the most valuable offensive player on the team at this point, as that is more than likely Prince Fielder; Fielder is doing a solid job of getting on base even though his power numbers have been disappointing.

Outfielders who unquestionably deserve spots over Braun include: Nate McLouth, Ryan Ludwick, Pat Burrell, Matt Holiday and Jason Bay. Arguments could be made for Rowand, Church and Nady over him as well, and Adam Dunn’s offense has been better than Braun’s, except I’ll give Braun the nod over him for defense.

I just don’t understand the great movement going on to get Braun in the All-Star team. I know it’s nothing but a popularity contest anyway, as the top three in votes right now are Alfonso Soriano, Kosuke Fukudome and Ken Griffey Jr (disgusting, isn’t it?). That doesn’t mean I have to blindly vote for Braun when I don’t think he deserves it, though.


9 responses to “Why vote for Braun when he doesn’t deserve it?

  1. What an anti-homer.

  2. douchebag

  3. Throw the Bill James stats out the window. I’d take Braun over just about anyone in the NL and I bet most GMs would agree.

  4. More thoughts … So Jason Bay deserves to be an all-star more than Braun? Please explain that one. And don’t mention OBP (You can take Bay’s 53 walks vs. Braun’s 12).

  5. How can I explain that without mentioning OBP? It’s WHY Bay is having a better season than Braun. The most important thing for a hitter to do is not make an out.

    Also, I wasn’t saying that I’d rather have all those other players I listed over Braun for the long haul. I was just arguing that they’ve had better seasons so far in 2008.

  6. I just want to weigh in finally on this. People are confusing the fact that the All-Star game “should” reflect players having the best season to that point, not the players you would rather have long term on your team. Of course, I would rather have Braun than Ludwick or Bay (most NL outfielders, but whatever) but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be rewarded for outperforming Braun to this point. This doesn’t mean I’m voting against Braun (I’m too lazy to vote anyway) but he certainly won’t be a snub if he gets beat out.

  7. Pingback: Right Field Bleachers » Blog Archive » In the News (6/17)

  8. Pingback: All things Ryan Braun « Brewers! Brewers! Keep Turnin’ Up the Heat!

  9. Pingback: 500th Post | Brewers! Brewers! Keep Turnin' Up the Heat!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s